← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 06 - Fasting Benefits
Transcript
We'll now look at some of the more specific benefits that are suggested to occur from fasting, including weight loss, blood sugar control, improved cholesterol levels, and improved cognitive function. And we'll see if the research lives up to the hype about fasting. Weight loss seems to be nearly everyone's favorite health related topic. So is fasting effective for shedding some or a lot of pounds? Much of the fasting research in humans comes from the Islamic holy month of Ramadan, where again, for 30 days people eat and drink only when the sun is set.
This provides a great opportunity to study shortened eating windows and has resulted in more than 600 published research papers. Weight changes have ranged from no differences to 5 % weight loss, with different effects sometimes being seen in men and women. When they are different, men tend to lose weight and women stay the same. It's important to remember that these Ramadan studies are observational in nature and there are a number of variables that change and are unaccounted for, such as the length of the daily fast due to the differences in time of year and geographical location, as well as changes in daily intake, activity and sleep patterns.
While these Ramadan studies are observational, there are a small but growing number of controlled trials looking at fasting practices. Taking all of the available research into consideration, a recent review paper found statistically significant weight reductions in 85 % of intermittent fasting trials. One study on overweight women that compared daily energy restriction to 25 % less per day with eating one small 500 calorie meal on two days per week found that both groups lost weight. But the women on the five Two diet improved their ability to regulate blood sugar more than the women who reduce calories every day.
Taking the five two diet a step further to alternate day fasting, we can find even more impressive weight loss when combined with exercise. One study reported an average weight loss of thirteen pounds over a 12 week period, and yet another small but very interesting pilot study used overweight participants who usually consumed their food within a 14 to 15 hour daily window they had. These people simply reduce their eating window to ten to eleven hours per day and without making any other dietary changes, these subjects lost weight. Which they were able to keep off for a year and also reported improvements in energy, hunger levels and sleep satisfaction.
Turning to animal research, one of the most compelling studies involved two groups of mice that were consuming the same amount of calories per day, but either throughout the whole day or within an 8 hour eating window. As you can see, and again, they all consume the same amount of calories. The group eating within an 8 hour window weighed 28 % less than the group eating throughout the whole day.
And this is not the only study to show that animals eating during a short and daily time window weigh drastically less than animals eating the exact same amount of food but dispersed throughout the whole day. Differences in weight have ranged from 8 to 31 % and to put that in human terms, a two hundred pound human losing just 15 % of their body weight would lose 30 pounds. Now there is an exception to this worth noting, and that is when the eating window was when the animal was supposed to be sleeping. Eating at night when we're normally asleep can actually have the opposite effects, evidenced by night shift workers who have higher rates of obesity, heart disease and cancer.
Outline
Suggested Benefits of Fasting
- Common Benefits Associated with Fasting:
- Weight loss
- Blood sugar control
- Improved cholesterol levels
- Improved cognitive function
Fasting and Weight Loss
- Research from Ramadan:
- Over 600 published studies on weight changes during Ramadan.
- Weight changes vary: no difference to 5% weight loss.
- Men tend to lose weight, women often stay the same.
- Ramadan studies are observational with many uncontrolled variables (e.g., length of fast, intake, activity, sleep patterns).
- Controlled Trials on Intermittent Fasting:
- 85% of intermittent fasting trials show statistically significant weight reductions.
- Example: Study on overweight women comparing daily energy restriction vs. 5:2 diet (500 calories on two days per week).
- Both groups lost weight.
- 5:2 diet group showed better blood sugar regulation.
- Alternate Day Fasting and Exercise:
- Study reported 13 pounds average weight loss over 12 weeks.
- Another study on reducing eating window to 10-11 hours/day:
- Subjects lost weight, kept it off for a year, and reported improvements in energy, hunger, and sleep.
Animal Research on Fasting
- Study on Mice:
- Two groups of mice consumed the same daily calories:
- One group ate throughout the day.
- Other group ate within an 8-hour window.
- Results: 8-hour window group weighed 28% less.
- Consistent Findings in Other Studies:
- Shortened eating windows result in significant weight loss.
- Weight differences range from 8% to 31% in animal studies.
- Exception: Eating During Sleep Periods:
- Eating during usual sleep times (e.g., night) can lead to negative outcomes.
- Evidenced by higher rates of obesity, heart disease, and cancer in night shift workers.
Quiz Question
Which of the following statements is supported by research on fasting and weight loss?
A) Men and women both consistently lose weight during Ramadan fasting.
B) Intermittent fasting is associated with significant weight loss in 85% of trials.
C) Mice that eat within an 8-hour window weigh the same as those that eat throughout the day.
D) Eating at night, when normally asleep, promotes weight loss.
B) Intermittent fasting is associated with significant weight loss in 85% of trials.