← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 07 - Fasting Concerns
Transcript
Now, while there is thus far very positive evidence of fasting helping with weight loss, it's also important to note that there is some scientific evidence that gives us some reason for concern. Am PK is a protein found in cells, and it detects whether you've eaten or not based on the amount of energy or ATP that is readily available. Therefore, a MPK is considered a metabolic sensor protein. When we haven't eaten food for a while, AM PK is activated.
There are some very important health benefits that are attributed to activating AM PK We'll discuss some of them when we talk about fasting mechanisms in a bit. But along with the health promoting effects, AMPK can also stimulate the growth and activity of hunger neurons, called AGRP neurons. In work from the lab of Bradford Lowell at Harvard, they showed that stimulating AMPK activates these hunger neurons and led to greater food intake, body weight and fat mass in mice. Conversely, blocking AMPK reduced hunger neuron firing and therefore hunger. This picture shows the ideal scenario for weight loss. We follow some type of dietary restriction in order to lose weight and then we keep it off and maintain that new weight.
What we commonly see is something like this however, losing weight and then putting some of it back on and settling into a slightly lower body weight than we initially started at. However, this undesirable scenario also occurs where people lose weight and then for one reason or another end up at a greater weight than where they started. So while the research on fasting in humans is promising, we always need to look at a topic in a variety of ways to really understand its impact.
It's possible that fasting could be a method that helps people lose weight but also increases their likelihood of weight regain after fasting for a period of time. Or this could happen in some but not others. Or it could not happen at all in humans. For now, we have some historical data that doesn't raise alarm bells for rapid weight regain. However, we do know that fasting activates AM PK and as we mentioned, a lot of benefits come from this activation but activating AMPK also strengthens the hunger neurons, which could help promote fat regain after fasting. Now, having said that, under our mechanisms section, we're going to talk about the positive impact of fasting on a different part of the weight regulation machinery.
There are a lot of different systems that are involved in weight regulation and feeding in the body, which is why we always need to go beyond the mechanism to see the actual weight loss or weight gain effects in the whole Organism. As we look beyond weight loss, blood sugar control is another area that is vital to optimal health, and fasting offers a great potential tool for improvements both for people with and without diabetes. Research in animals using shortened eating windows has resulted in dramatic improvements in blood sugar control. This graphic shows nondiabetic diabetic rats that were either eating normally, shown as the solid line, or undergoing a daily 9 hour eating window shown as the dotted line.
Area under the curve, or AUC, is a way to measure how much and for how long Blood sugar is raised after a meal, and we see drastic differences between the groups. Measurements are shown for one month and we see improvements in the eating window group and worsen blood glucose levels in the control group. We can also look to human trials using a variety of fasting methods that have also measured markers and blood area control. The study, looking at the habits of over 1000 women, found that each three hour increase in nighttime fasting duration was associated with a roughly 20 % reduced odds of having elevated blood sugar.
This speaks to the longterm efficacy of shortened daily eating windows. In addition to this, most of the human alternate day fasting studies have found improvements in at least one marker of glucose regulation, though some have found no differences. Keeping in line with the blood sugar improvements, favorable changes in levels of cholesterol and triglycerides have also been reported. For example, we've seen decreases in total cholesterol of 10 to 21 % and decreases in triglycerides of 14 to 42 % in subjects that were normal weight, overweight and obese people.
Following the five two big days, little days diet showed improvements in cholesterol levels that were similar to those seen by traditional dieting. And one alternate day fasting study showed improvements in HDL cholesterol and triglycerides, but also increased LDL cholesterol, which is generally thought to be less favorable. More research in humans will provide additional insights, but the existing animal research is also quite compelling. Here we have two groups of animals that consume the same amount of calories each day, but one of them consumed them within a 12 hour window, while the other group had access to food throughout the entire day, as you can see.
Mice fed during a 12 hour window had 50 % lower levels of triglycerides than mice eating the same diet and the same number of calories spread throughout the day. Another study that fed animals either a normal diet or a high fat diet and either in an 8 hour window or throughout the whole day also showed promising results. On a normal diet, there were no differences in cholesterol levels shown on the left. However, mice on a high fat diet that was consumed in an 8 hour window showed nearly a 50 % decrease in cholesterol levels compared with animals eating the same food spread throughout the day.
So, considering the available evidence, it seems that someone's baseline dietary habits, both food quality as well as food timing appear to impact the efficacy of shortened daily eating window programs.
Outline
Concerns Regarding Fasting and Weight Regain
- AMPK and Hunger Neurons:
- AMPK is a metabolic sensor protein activated during fasting.
- Health benefits of AMPK activation include improved metabolism and energy regulation.
- Activation of AMPK also stimulates hunger neurons (AGRP neurons), potentially leading to increased food intake, body weight, and fat mass.
- Research from Harvard's Bradford Lowell lab shows that stimulating AMPK can lead to weight and fat mass gain in mice.
- Blocking AMPK reduces hunger neuron activity and hunger.
- Weight Loss and Regain:
- Ideal Scenario: Lose weight and maintain new, lower weight.
- Common Scenario: Lose weight, regain some, and settle at a slightly lower weight than before.
- Undesirable Scenario: Lose weight, regain more than the initial weight.
- Potential concern: Fasting might help with initial weight loss but increase the likelihood of weight regain due to AMPK activation.
Fasting and Blood Sugar Control
- Animal Research:
- Shortened eating windows in animal studies show dramatic improvements in blood sugar control.
- Example: Nondiabetic and diabetic rats on a 9-hour eating window show lower blood sugar levels (measured by Area Under the Curve - AUC) compared to those eating normally.
- Human Studies:
- Study on over 1,000 women found that each 3-hour increase in nighttime fasting duration was associated with a 20% reduced odds of elevated blood sugar.
- Alternate day fasting in humans shows improvements in glucose regulation markers, though some studies found no differences.
Fasting and Cholesterol Levels
- Human Studies:
- Fasting, including the 5:2 diet, shows reductions in total cholesterol (10-21%) and triglycerides (14-42%) in normal weight, overweight, and obese people.
- Some studies show improvements in HDL cholesterol and triglycerides, but an increase in LDL cholesterol (less favorable).
- Animal Studies:
- Mice fed within a 12-hour window had 50% lower triglyceride levels than those eating the same diet throughout the day.
- Mice on a high-fat diet with an 8-hour eating window showed a 50% decrease in cholesterol levels compared to those eating throughout the day.
- Impact of Baseline Dietary Habits:
- Baseline food quality and timing influence the efficacy of shortened daily eating window programs.
Quiz Question
What potential concern arises from the activation of AMPK during fasting?
A) AMPK activation reduces hunger and leads to sustained weight loss.
B) AMPK activation may increase hunger neuron activity, potentially leading to weight regain.
C) AMPK activation solely improves blood sugar control without affecting weight.
D) AMPK activation leads to a significant decrease in body fat with no risk of weight regain.
Answer:
B) AMPK activation may increase hunger neuron activity, potentially leading to weight regain.