← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 05 - The Seven Countries Study
Transcript
The famous Seven Countries Study from the nineteen sixties was the first study of its kind to examine diet and lifestyle and its relationship to cardiovascular disease risk factors across a variety of populations. Nearly 12.000 thousand males between the ages of 40 and 60 were enrolled in seven countries from 4 regions of the world, the United States, Northern Europe, Southern Europe and Japan. The study population from Greece came from the rural areas where religious observances, including dietary habits, were an important part of the traditions and lifestyle.
This group was very healthy, following what we now think of as the Mediterranean diet is often touted as one of, if not the healthiest dietary pattern. If you have heard of the Mediterranean diet, you probably think of olive oil, nuts and fish consumption. What people rarely consider is that the Greek Orthodox religion includes 180 to 200 days per year of some type of dietary restriction during the fasting periods. Animal products are often excluded, though certain types of seafoods such as shrimp, lobster, crabs and snails are allowed in all fasting days throughout the year.
More recently controlled studies that have incorporated these religious fasting practices have confirmed their importance as a component of the Mediterranean diet, resulting in lower body weight and improved lipid profiles compared with people who simply followed the same food choices without fasting. The Mormon religion also incorporates fasting, but in a different manner. One Sunday each month, Latter day Saints observe a fast day where they do not eat or drink for two consecutive meals. Typically, they will eat dinner on Saturday and then not eat or drink again until dinner on Sunday. Observational studies of Mormons who follow this practice just one day per month show significantly decreased risks of heart disease and diabetes compared to non meal skippers who otherwise have similar health and lifestyles.
Looking back to the Great Depression is very interesting to see that life expectancy actually rose by over six years during the period between 1929 and 1932 While there was likely a good deal of overall calorie restriction, it also seems safe to say that many people were probably going to bed without dinner and or skipping breakfast. Although overall calorie restriction and fasting often go hand in hand, it has been shown in animal models that fasting does offer benefits that are independent of calorie intake, meaning a reduction in calories is not solely what's responsible for the favorable changes. To think in broad terms, a high calorie intake increases disease risk, while a low calorie intake decreases your risks of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, stroke, cancer, and possibly even degenerative brain disorders.
As I mentioned, calorie reduction is often, though not always, attached to periods of fasting. There are a number of ways to reduce or control calorie intake, including continuous restriction, meaning reducing your calorie intake by a consistent amount each day. Or intermittently, which is what we're talking about with planned fasting periods. It has been observed that continuous calorie restriction in the context of a nutrient dense diet can provide health benefits. However, too much restriction can cause malnutrition, decrease bone density, and adverse effects on hormonal and reproductive function in both men and women. Another important difference is that continuous calorie restriction may be missing one of the most important components, which is the refeeding.
Calorie restriction can lower many of the body's growth factors, but after lowering them, you still have to rebuild and regrow the systems. Continuous calorie restriction doesn't offer these rebuilding periods in the same way because it is missing a critical start. Stop signaling of feasting and fasting now. At this point it is worth taking a small detour to consider the differences between starvation and planned fasting. Starvation is involuntary or in the case of eating disorders, voluntary absence of food resulting in longterm food restriction. In contrast, fasting is deliberately abstaining from food for a preset amount of time in the context of a diet that otherwise includes longer periods of sufficient intake, when adverse effects, such as a reduction in metabolic rate and inability to reproduce our scene, is typically with longterm food deprivation or starvation.
Weight regain after long term caloric restriction often results in accelerated fat storage, which scientists referred to as ketchup fat. In contrast, short periods of fasting interspersed with periods of food security and even slight excess appear to be very beneficial.
Outline
The Seven Countries Study and Mediterranean Diet
- Seven Countries Study:
- First study to examine diet, lifestyle, and cardiovascular disease risk across various populations.
- Involved nearly 12,000 males aged 40-60 from the U.S., Northern Europe, Southern Europe, and Japan.
- Greek Orthodox population from rural Greece was notably healthy.
- Mediterranean Diet:
- Famous for including olive oil, nuts, and fish.
- Greek Orthodox fasting practices included 180-200 days/year of dietary restrictions.
- Fasting often excludes animal products, except certain seafoods.
- Impact of Fasting:
- Recent controlled studies confirm the health benefits of these fasting practices.
- Results in lower body weight and improved lipid profiles.
Fasting in Other Religious Practices
- Mormon Fasting Practices:
- Fast one Sunday per month, skipping two consecutive meals.
- Observational studies show reduced risks of heart disease and diabetes.
Historical Context of Fasting and Calorie Restriction
- Great Depression:
- Life expectancy rose by over six years between 1929-1932.
- Likely due to overall calorie restriction and skipping meals.
- Calorie Restriction vs. Fasting:
- High calorie intake increases disease risk; low intake decreases risks of various diseases.
- Fasting benefits independent of calorie intake observed in animal models.
Types of Calorie Restriction
- Continuous Restriction:
- Consistent daily reduction in calorie intake.
- Offers health benefits but can cause malnutrition, decreased bone density, and hormonal imbalances if overdone.
- Intermittent Restriction (Fasting):
- Involves planned periods of fasting.
- Includes refeeding periods, crucial for growth and regeneration.
Fasting vs. Starvation
- Starvation:
- Involuntary or voluntary long-term food restriction.
- Leads to adverse effects such as reduced metabolic rate and reproductive issues.
- Fasting:
- Deliberate and time-limited abstention from food.
- Offers benefits by alternating between fasting and refeeding periods.
- Weight Regain After Caloric Restriction:
- Long-term restriction often leads to accelerated fat storage (catch-up fat).
- Short periods of fasting with refeeding are beneficial.
Quiz Question
Which of the following statements best describes the difference between continuous calorie restriction and intermittent fasting?
A) Continuous calorie restriction involves periods of fasting followed by refeeding, while intermittent fasting does not.
B) Continuous calorie restriction provides more health benefits than intermittent fasting.
C) Intermittent fasting includes refeeding periods that help with growth and regeneration, while continuous calorie restriction may lack these critical periods.
D) Both continuous calorie restriction and intermittent fasting lead to long-term food deprivation.
C) Intermittent fasting includes refeeding periods that help with growth and regeneration, while continuous calorie restriction may lack these critical periods.