← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 03 - Fat and Physical Activity
Transcript
In the nineteen seventies, researchers first showed that exercise partially protects rats from weight gain when they eat a fattening diet, and this has since been confirmed many times. Human randomized trials came later and have also supported the idea that exercise, even without dieting, helps prevent the slow weight gain that most of us experience over time. Aside from the simple fact that physical activity burns calories, some evidence suggests that exercise helps maintain the circuits in the brain that regulate appetite and adiposity, naturally keeping our calorie intake within the right range. We discussed these brain circuits in more detail in the course on appetite. Although exercise protects against fat gain, that doesn't mean you can eat whatever you want and burn it off.
Most of us aren't burning through 12.000 thousand calories a day like Michael Phelps. Regular physical activity can make you more resistant to the fattening effect of food, but it doesn't make you immune. Exercise can also cause fat loss, particularly when combined with a slimming diet. Many studies have reported unimpressive fat loss from exercise alone, but if you look closely. You see that in most cases, the volunteers weren't actually exercising very much.
This is because adherence to an exercise regime is often challenging because of the time and effort involved. Later in the course, we'll share strategies for monitoring your physical activity and making it a sustainable part of your life. But for now, the point is that if we only consider studies that used monitored exercise. And therefore, where adherence was excellent, they showed that exercise can actually cause substantial fat loss. But there's a very important caveat here, which is that different people can respond very differently to exercise. To illustrate that, let's consider a study that assigned 35 people who were overweight or obese to a 12 week supervised exercise program.
The exercise regimen was designed to burn 500 calories five times a week, for a total of twenty five hundred calories per. Week on average, volunteers lost eight pounds of fat over the course of the 12 week study. Not bad, but the individual data are more telling. The best loss was an impressive 21 pounds of fat. The worst loss, however, was actually a gain of six pounds of fat. Two additional volunteers lost no fat at all, although it's worth keeping in mind that the other 32 did lose fat. So the response to exercise is highly individual why? To answer this question, the researchers also measured the volunteers food intake before and after the intervention.
It turns out that the people who didn't lose fat had unintentionally increased their calorie intake substantially in response to the exercise, negating the extra calories they burned. In contrast, the people who did lose fat hadn't increased their calorie intake in response to exercise. In fact, it even decreased a little bit. So the appetite centers in the brain respond differently to exercise depending on who you are. Some of us work up a big appetite while others don't, and only you can determine where you fall on that spectrum. Wherever you are on it, it's important to know because it will determine the degree to which exercise will support your fat loss goal.
The overall finding of this study, however, is that about 90 % of people don't fully compensate for the calories they burn during regular exercise by eating more. And therefore exercise causes them to lose a meaningful amount of fat. There are exceptions, but most of us are not exceptions. Not only does physical activity prevent fat gain and accelerate fat loss, it also helps maintain fat loss over the long term. This is particularly true for aerobic activity, but anaerobic activity is helpful as well.
The benefits of physical activity for weight and health are compelling enough that it should be part of any serious fat loss or general health program. Conversely, insufficient physical activity can be quite harmful.
Outline
Historical Evidence on Exercise and Weight Gain
- 1970s Research:
- Initial studies showed exercise partially protects rats from weight gain on a fattening diet.
- Subsequent confirmations through multiple studies.
- Human Randomized Trials:
- Later studies confirmed exercise helps prevent slow weight gain over time.
- Exercise burns calories and may maintain brain circuits regulating appetite and adiposity.
Exercise and Fat Gain
- Exercise Does Not Equal Unlimited Eating:
- Exercise increases resistance to fattening effects of food but does not make one immune.
- Only extreme athletes like Michael Phelps burn extraordinarily high calories (e.g., 12,000/day).
Exercise and Fat Loss
- Combination with Diet:
- Exercise, particularly when combined with a slimming diet, promotes fat loss.
- Many studies show unimpressive fat loss with exercise alone due to poor adherence to regimes.
- Monitored exercise studies show substantial fat loss with proper adherence.
Individual Variability in Response to Exercise
- 12-Week Exercise Program Study:
- Study on 35 overweight/obese individuals over 12 weeks, burning 500 calories five times a week.
- Average fat loss was 8 pounds, but individual results varied significantly.
- Best loss: 21 pounds of fat; worst case: gain of 6 pounds of fat; 2 participants lost no fat.
Factors Influencing Fat Loss Variability
- Food Intake Response to Exercise:
- People who didn’t lose fat unintentionally increased calorie intake post-exercise.
- Those who lost fat either maintained or slightly decreased calorie intake.
- Brain's appetite centers respond differently to exercise across individuals.
Key Findings on Exercise and Fat Loss
- General Population Response:
- About 90% of people don’t fully compensate for calories burned with increased eating.
- Exercise generally results in meaningful fat loss for most people.
- Both aerobic and anaerobic activities are beneficial for maintaining long-term fat loss.
Importance of Physical Activity
- Physical Activity and Health:
- Essential for any serious fat loss or general health program.
- Insufficient physical activity is harmful.
Quiz Question
What is one reason why different people may respond differently to exercise in terms of fat loss?
A) Some people naturally burn more calories during exercise.
B) Some people unintentionally increase their calorie intake in response to exercise.
C) Some people’s muscles convert fat to muscle more effectively.
D) Some people are genetically immune to gaining fat from a poor diet.
B) Some people unintentionally increase their calorie intake in response to exercise.