How Much Physical Activity Do We Need?
← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 05 - Activity and Fitness of Preindustrial People
Transcript
So we assume, quite reasonably, that our ancient ancestors were way more active than us. But we can't directly study how these humans live because, well, they're all long dead. One way we can get a picture of the activity levels for which our bodies have evolved is a study preindustrial people. Many of these groups live in ways that strongly resemble that of archaic humans. Let's start by looking at the Ache of Paraguay. An anthropologist who lived with the tribe for many years reported that Ache men would hunt almost daily. And these excursions were very physically demanding.
They had to hurdle, fall in trees and weave between branches and vines. G, p s. Data suggested that they traveled on average about 6 to 9 miles per day. Let's look on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean to East Africa. The Hadza are a foraging population living in northern Tanzania. Similar to the ACE, the Hadza have to navigate uneven terrain, and they capture nearly all of their food by hunting and gathering wild resources.
A team of researchers measured their moderate to vigorous activity levels using activity monitors. They found that hods off foragers perform, on average one hundred thirty five minutes of moderate to vigorous activity per day, more than 14 times as much as the average American. Furthermore, they maintain these activity patterns across the lifespan, from youth all the way to old age. Now, it might sound like these individuals are performing a daunting amount of activity. I mean, how many of us can possibly fit in one hundred thirty five minutes of exercise a day? But it's actually not an unreasonable amount when you consider the context in which this activity occurs.
Movement is an integral part of these people's lives. They're not isolating time for formally exercising, like they're not going to a gym for two hours a day. Instead, they're doing things like digging, throwing, climbing, carrying children, and so on. In other words, they punctuate their days with regular bouts of a wide range of physical activities. So when you're contemplating how to fit activity into your own life, keep that in mind. So it certainly seems that people in preindustrial societies are more physically active overall compared to counterparts living in Western countries, suggesting again that we have evolved to move.
What about fitness? Well, let's start by looking at folks in the US Just to put things into perspective, the average VO2 Max value among 20 to 29 year old American women is about 37 milliliters per kilogram per minute, and the average among American men is a little higher, at 45 milliliters per kilogram per minute. Now let's compare these values to people from preindustrial societies around the world. First, the chimanet of Bolivia show an average VO2 Max of about 51 milliliters per kilogram per minute for ages 20 to 39 and then 43 milliliters per kilogram per minute for ages 40 to 59 A study of 20 to 29 year old Ache and Paraguay found that the women had VO2 Max values of about 42 milliliters per kilogram per minute.
And men averaged 62 milliliters per kilogram per minute. Very impressive. Finally, a study of Inuit in the Canadian Arctic community of igloo leak reported that these people had VO2 maxes of 49 to 54 milliliters per kilogram per minute. So people in preindustrial society show VO2 Max values as much as 38 % higher than those of American adults. Plus they seem to maintain good aerobic fitness even as they reach old age. But the good news is, this is not at all out of reach.
If you regularly participate in vigorous physical activity, you absolutely can achieve Cardio respiratory fitness levels comparable to the preindustrial people of days gone by. And this is a worthy goal, because, as we will see in another lesson, higher fitness is tightly associated with better health. So let's quickly summarize what we covered here. For most of our history as a species, humans have been highly physically active. We, in effect, evolved to move. This is because physical activity has historically been essential for survival and reproduction.
Men and women in preindustrial societies, living in a fashion that resembles that of our ancient ancestors, are highly active and exhibit remarkable physical fitness. Cultural and technological advances have made physical activity nearly optional in modern Westernized societies like ours, and it is likely that our health suffers as a result.
Outline
Understanding Activity Levels of Ancient Humans Through Preindustrial Societies
- Challenges in Studying Ancient Activity
- We assume our ancient ancestors were more active, but direct study is impossible since they are long gone.
- Alternative Approach: Study preindustrial societies that live similarly to archaic humans.
- Case Study: The Ache of Paraguay
- Daily Activity: Ache men hunt almost daily, engaging in physically demanding tasks like hurdling fallen trees and weaving through branches.
- Activity Levels: GPS data shows they travel about 6 to 9 miles per day on average.
- Case Study: The Hadza of Tanzania
- Foraging Lifestyle: The Hadza navigate uneven terrain and hunt/gather nearly all their food.
- Activity Levels: Researchers found they perform an average of 135 minutes of moderate to vigorous activity daily, more than 14 times that of the average American.
- Lifespan Consistency: Hadza maintain high activity levels from youth through old age.
Fitness Comparisons: Preindustrial vs. Western Societies
- Modern Western VO2 Max Values
- US Averages:
- 20-29 year old American women: ~37 ml/kg/min.
- 20-29 year old American men: ~45 ml/kg/min.
- VO2 Max in Preindustrial Societies
- The Chimane of Bolivia:
- Ages 20-39: ~51 ml/kg/min.
- Ages 40-59: ~43 ml/kg/min.
- The Ache of Paraguay:
- Women: ~42 ml/kg/min.
- Men: ~62 ml/kg/min.
- The Inuit of Canada:
- VO2 Max: 49-54 ml/kg/min.
- Significance
- People in preindustrial societies show VO2 Max values up to 38% higher than those of American adults.
- They maintain good aerobic fitness into old age.
Implications for Modern Society
- Achieving High Fitness Levels
- With regular participation in vigorous physical activity, it is possible to reach fitness levels similar to those in preindustrial societies.
- Health Benefits: Higher fitness is closely linked to better health outcomes.
Conclusion
- Evolution and Physical Activity
- Humans evolved to be highly physically active, as it was essential for survival and reproduction.
- Modern Challenges: Technological advances have made physical activity optional in modern societies, likely leading to negative health consequences.
Quiz Question
Which of the following statements best describes the activity levels of the Hadza people in comparison to the average American?
A) The Hadza people perform the same amount of moderate to vigorous activity as the average American.
B) The Hadza people perform over 14 times as much moderate to vigorous activity daily compared to the average American.
C) The Hadza people are less active than the average American due to their foraging lifestyle.
D) The Hadza people do not engage in any moderate to vigorous physical activity.
B) The Hadza people perform over 14 times as much moderate to vigorous activity daily compared to the average American.