How Much Physical Activity Do We Need?
← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 04 - What is Biologically Normal
Transcript
We often hear people talk about the health benefits of exercise. This is kind of funny if you stop and think about it kind of implies that the natural baseline is a life of inactivity. And then adding an exercise raises our bodily function above that, almost like exercise is a supplement. But should we view exercise this way? In fact, the opposite is true. High levels of physical activity and fitness are the biologically normal state for humans. To understand why this is, we need to go back, way back to the beginning of our evolution as a species. According to fossil evidence, the earliest examples of what we might call humans appeared on this planet about 2 4 million years ago.
For about 84,000 thousand generations, our ancestors lived as hunter gatherers. Physical activity was essential for these people to survive, and it's not hard to imagine why. One thing, there were no targets or Walmarts around, so hunting and foraging was probably necessary on most days just to acquire enough food and water. Secondly, as you no doubt realize, the wild environment is a very dangerous place. So at times our ancestors would have had to flee from animals or even from other people. Human daily life changed substantially when people began domesticating plants and animals and transitioned from a nomadic lifestyle of hunting and gathering to sedentary agricultural production.
Next we come to the Industrial revolution, which led to the development of cities built environments that are obviously totally unlike the African rainforests in Savannah where humans had spent most of their history living and evolving. That brings us to today with the advent of the digital revolution. If you think about how most of us go about our day compared to say our great grandparents and further back, it is clear that we have quite literally engineered physical activity out of our lives. I'm sure you can think of plenty of examples of Labor saving tools in your own life that all contribute to this effect, like dishwashers, washing machines, our various kitchen devices, and of course the vehicles and infrastructure that make it easier for us to save time and move around less, like automobiles, elevators and escalators.
And if we're given a choice, we will usually pick the easy way, the way that demands the least effort. You know this. How many people, when presented with the option of escalators versus stairs, do you think actually choose to take the stairs? Yeah, not very many. When given the option, only about 5 % will take the stairs. Similarly, only about 35 % of people will pass up an elevator ride in favor of stairs, even though stairs are often faster than waiting for an elevator.
The point is we naturally gravitate to whatever conserves energy. This tendency probably served us well in the natural environment, but it gets us into trouble. Now let's look at recent trends in leisure time physical activity from men and women in the US over the past 30 years. This graph shows the percentage of Americans reporting no leisure time physical activity. Now we see that in 1988 not that long ago, about 19 % of women and 11 % of men reported no leisure time physical activity.
In 2010 the proportion of American men and women who reported no leisure time physical activity jumped all the way to 43 and 51 %, respectively. So we're moving less at work, and we're moving less for fun. This is a pretty bleak trend. Why haven't we genetically adapted to this reduced activity? Well, generally speaking, it takes a long time for evolution to select for variants of genes that help animals thrive in novel environments. But on an evolutionary scale, our environment has totally transformed in the space of just a few generations, not long at all.
Furthermore, there simply hasn't been much selection for genes that would help us cope with our sedentary modern world, because most of the problems associated with inactivity emerged later in life, after reproduction. So the world around us has changed dramatically, but our genomes and our bodies are essentially still paleolithic. Perhaps the most compelling evidence suggesting that we have not adapted to sedentary lifestyles is the rapid rise of diseases associated with physical activity.
Type 2 diabetes is an apt example. Between 1990 and 2015 the % of the US population living with type 2 diabetes nearly tripled. Clearly, genes that relate to insulin and blood sugar control cannot have changed that much in the space of just about a generation, but our lives certainly have. In summary, we should consider high levels of physical activity and the fitness that results from such a regiment to be the biologically normal human state. In fact, it is activity deficiency and the consequent health issues that many humans now experience that are abnormal.
Outline
Introduction: Rethinking the Role of Exercise
- Exercise as a Supplement?
- Common perception: Exercise is an add-on that enhances bodily function.
- Reality Check: High levels of physical activity and fitness are biologically normal for humans, not a supplement.
Evolutionary Perspective on Physical Activity
- Hunter-Gatherer Ancestors
- Evolution Timeline: Humans have existed for about 2.4 million years.
- Hunter-Gatherer Lifestyle: For 84,000 generations, our ancestors relied on physical activity for survival, including hunting, foraging, and fleeing from danger.
- Transition to Agriculture
- Shift in Daily Life: From nomadic hunting and gathering to sedentary agricultural production.
- Industrial and Digital Revolutions
- Impact of the Industrial Revolution: Development of cities and built environments unlike the natural settings where humans evolved.
- Modern Sedentary Lifestyle: The digital revolution has engineered physical activity out of our daily lives through labor-saving tools and conveniences.
Modern Sedentary Behavior
- Preference for Energy Conservation
- Examples: Dishwashers, washing machines, automobiles, elevators, and escalators reduce physical exertion.
- Human Tendency: People naturally choose the path of least resistance, e.g., only about 5% take the stairs when escalators are available.
- Trends in Leisure Time Physical Activity
- Decline Over Time: In 1988, 19% of women and 11% of men reported no leisure time physical activity. By 2010, these figures rose to 51% for women and 43% for men.
Lack of Genetic Adaptation to Inactivity
- Evolutionary Timeframe
- Slow Genetic Change: Evolution takes time; our rapid environmental changes haven't allowed for genetic adaptation to sedentary lifestyles.
- Paleolithic Bodies in a Modern World: Our genomes and bodies are still adapted to a more active, ancient lifestyle.
- Rise of Diseases Linked to Inactivity
- Example: Type 2 Diabetes
- Rapid Increase: Between 1990 and 2015, the percentage of the U.S. population with type 2 diabetes nearly tripled.
- Mismatch: Genetic changes related to insulin and blood sugar control haven't kept pace with lifestyle changes.
Conclusion: Physical Activity as the Normal Human State
- Activity Deficiency as the Abnormality
- High levels of physical activity and fitness should be considered the biological norm.
- The health issues stemming from inactivity are the true abnormalities.
Quiz Question
Which of the following best explains why high levels of physical activity and fitness should be considered the normal human state?
A) Humans have always been naturally sedentary, and physical activity is a recent invention.
B) The modern sedentary lifestyle has been genetically adapted to, making physical activity less necessary.
C) Physical activity only became important after the digital revolution introduced sedentary behaviors.
D) High levels of physical activity were essential for survival for most of human history, and our bodies are still adapted to this active lifestyle.
D) High levels of physical activity were essential for survival for most of human history, and our bodies are still adapted to this active lifestyle.