← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 02 - Fears of Fasting
Transcript
Many people believe that not eating for more than a few hours will put the body into starvation mode and lower their metabolic rate. However, evidence shows you can fast for two to three days before a lowered metabolic rate is actually seen. In fact, metabolic rate can actually increase by up to 15 % during short-term fasting due to increased stress hormones. People may also claim not to be able to think properly when hungry.
One study created special foods that were essentially calorie-free, allowing research to be performed when the subjects didn't know whether or not they were having any calorie intake. When the subjects were unaware of their intake, cognitive performance, activity levels, and mood were not adversely affected by two days of calorie deprivation. In fact, increased concentration and alertness is even reported during fasting, possibly due to increased levels of stress hormones. This is one of the reasons why Later, we'll talk about why fasting might not be right for everyone. And to think of this another way, if adult brain function rapidly deteriorated when food was not available, the ability to obtain food would get much tougher, which would not be very helpful from a survival or evolutionary perspective.
The question of whether people will overcompensate after a fast and inadvertently increase their energy intake is an obvious one. However, research does not support this notion skipping a whole day or skipping one meal. People may eat slightly more during the next day or next meal, but will still end up in a net deficit. It seems that people often forget to distinguish between skipping meals and simply delaying meals with regard to overeating and increasing total calorie intake. My blood sugar will drop too much is another common fear when suggesting somebody skips a meal.
While people may feel hungry or like they need sugar, which are subjective signs of hypoglycemia, healthy adults can fast without any real metabolic problems, meaning nothing is actually wrong. You may just be uncomfortable for a little while. And even people who are quite thin will have over 100,000 thousand calories stored in their bodies. So there are definitely calories that can be burned for energy. So while it is possible to feel tired while fasting, there are mechanisms in place to allow your body to find the energy it needs. However, fatigue that won't go away is not normal while fasting. If you experience excessive fatigue, you should stop fasting immediately and seek medical advice. We'll talk more about exercising while fasting later, but for those worried about burning muscle, you can rest easy because one of the things that fasting does is actually increase growth hormone production, a hormone that helps to burn fat and build muscle.
And importantly, during fasting it plays a role in decreasing muscle protein breakdown. As far back as 100 years ago, it was shown that protein breakdown did not begin to increase until the third day of fasting, and that the energy used by the body during the first two to three days of fasting was largely derived from stored carbohydrate and fat. A more recent study supports this idea by showing that the appearance of urea nitrogen, which reflects muscle protein breakdown, was not increased at 36 hours of fasting but was increased at 60 hours. And from another common sense standpoint, why would the human body store energy so easily as fat if it were going to burn protein from your muscles instead? And one other common fear surrounding fasting is that it can create unhealthy eating patterns and lead to eating disorders.
Well, it is not recommended that someone with an eating disorder begin any type of extreme fasting program. A recent study on the safety of alternate day fasting found that it produces minimal adverse outcomes and even led to decreased depression and binge eating while improving body image perception. So now that we've hopefully set aside some of your fears surrounding fasting, we can now consider some of the different forms of intermittent fasting that are practiced.
Outline
Misconceptions About Fasting
- Starvation Mode:
- Common belief: Not eating for a few hours leads to starvation mode and lowers metabolic rate.
- Evidence: Metabolic rate does not decrease until after 2-3 days of fasting; it may actually increase by up to 15% during short-term fasting due to stress hormones.
- Cognitive Function During Fasting:
- Belief: Hunger impairs cognitive function.
- Evidence: A study with calorie-free foods showed no adverse effects on cognitive performance, activity levels, or mood during two days of calorie deprivation. Increased concentration and alertness were reported, likely due to increased stress hormones.
- Overeating After Fasting:
- Concern: Fasting will lead to overeating and increased calorie intake afterward.
- Evidence: Research shows that people may eat slightly more after a fast, but they still end up in a net calorie deficit.
- Blood Sugar Concerns:
- Fear: Skipping meals will cause dangerously low blood sugar.
- Evidence: Healthy adults can fast without real metabolic problems; feelings of hunger are subjective and do not indicate actual hypoglycemia.
- Energy Availability During Fasting:
- Misconception: Fasting causes a significant energy deficit.
- Evidence: Even thin individuals have over 100,000 calories stored in their bodies, which can be used for energy during fasting.
Muscle Preservation During Fasting
- Muscle Loss Concerns:
- Fear: Fasting leads to muscle loss.
- Evidence: Fasting increases growth hormone production, which helps burn fat and build muscle while reducing muscle protein breakdown. Protein breakdown does not significantly increase until the third day of fasting.
- Protein Breakdown Studies:
- Historical Study: Protein breakdown does not increase until the third day of fasting; energy comes from stored carbs and fat initially.
- Recent Study: Urea nitrogen, a marker of muscle protein breakdown, does not increase at 36 hours of fasting but does increase at 60 hours.
Fasting and Eating Disorders
- Eating Disorder Concerns:
- Fear: Fasting can create unhealthy eating patterns and lead to eating disorders.
- Evidence: A study on alternate-day fasting showed minimal adverse outcomes, decreased depression, and binge eating, while improving body image perception.
Transition to Different Forms of Intermittent Fasting
- Next Steps:
- Having addressed common fears, the course will explore different forms of intermittent fasting.
Quiz Question
What has research shown about cognitive performance during short-term fasting?
A) Cognitive performance decreases significantly.
B) Cognitive performance and alertness remain unaffected.
C) Cognitive performance improves slightly but alertness decreases.
D) Cognitive performance decreases but physical performance improves.
B) Cognitive performance and alertness remain unaffected.