← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 15 - Shortened Eating Window
Transcript
For someone who has never fasted before, shortened eating windows may be the best place to start. Anecdotally, men and women tend to respond differently to shortened eating windows, with females potentially responding better to a slightly larger eating window. Regardless, pick a 10 to 12 hour window to start with and you can gradually try peeling that window back to 8 to 10 hours. Water is fine outside of this window, as it's really more about caloric intake, interestingly.
Recent animal research has shown that following this type of schedule, 5 days per week allowing 2 days of anytime meeting is actually enough to confer the majority of the benefits. So following a shortened eating window 70 % of the time may actually give you 90 % of the benefits. Determining your window is something that has not yet been established by scientific research studies, but I will offer a few guidelines. To begin with, it should fit within the context of your lifestyle, because if it won't work logistically, you're not going to be able to stick with it.
Time of year, believe it or not, may actually be one of the biggest determinants of when your eating window should be. A good rule of thumb is to try and consume most of your food when the sun is out. This is due to interactions within our body of our nighttime hormones like melatonin with hormones associated with eating such as insulin. Of course, depending on where you live and what your lifestyle dictates, this isn't always possible, but aiming to consume most of your food when it's light out is a sound approach.
This means meal times can be more flexible during the summer as you can have an 8 hour window from noon to eight pm for example. While a window that includes breakfast, such as nine to six may be a better idea during the shorter days of winter, the question of whether or not coffee will break your fast is a good one. The short answer is that from a body clock standpoint, coffee will start your daily clock. This is probably a good thing for most people, even when they're avoiding other food in the morning. Beyond that, coffee is fine to have during a fast, and likely may even help your cause by increasing lipolysis or fat breakdown, interestingly.
Decaf won't have the same effect as it's the caffeine that is actually providing much of the shortterm benefits. Some people have also taken to adding butter and or coconut oil into the coffee. Because neither of these will increase your blood sugar or insulin levels, you can in fact consume them while effectively remaining in your fast. However, your blood levels of triglycerides will likely increase and this may or may not become a problem, but it's worth noting that it's not completely innocuous. Eating or skipping breakfast is a topic that is often hotly debated. Some research suggests that when people who normally eat breakfast are made to skip breakfast, they don't do as well.
And when people who normally skip breakfast are made to eat breakfast, they don't really feel much better. However, other studies show that after enough time to adapt to the new routine, breakfast tends to be of benefit in blood sugar control, satiety, and it can even reduce hunger later in the day. Some people say they're never hungry or always hungry in the morning. If you decide to try something new, know that there is a large degree of trainability of the hunger hormones. This means following a new pattern for at least a week or so may be necessary in order to give it a proper chance. They're also the seasonal considerations that we just talked about.
And finally, meal frequency within the window doesn't seem to be as important as you might expect. The notion that eating multiple small meals is healthier than skipping meals or eating big meals really just isn't true. So if you like eating two to three larger meals, then that's fine. And if you like eating four to six smaller meals, that's fine too.
Outline
Starting with Shortened Eating Windows
- Introduction to Shortened Eating Windows:
- Ideal starting point for fasting beginners.
- Men and women may respond differently, with women potentially benefiting from a slightly larger eating window.
- Suggested starting window: 10 to 12 hours, which can be reduced to 8 to 10 hours over time.
- Water and Caloric Intake:
- Water is allowed outside the eating window, as the focus is on restricting caloric intake.
- Animal Research Insights:
- Following a shortened eating window 5 days a week (70% adherence) may provide 90% of the benefits.
- Allows for some flexibility with 2 days of unrestricted eating.
- Determining Your Eating Window:
- Should fit within the context of your lifestyle for long-term adherence.
- Seasonal considerations:
- Summer: Longer eating windows (e.g., noon to 8 p.m.).
- Winter: Shorter eating windows (e.g., 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.).
- Aim to eat most food when the sun is out due to interactions between nighttime and eating-related hormones.
- Coffee and Fasting:
- Coffee starts your daily body clock and is generally beneficial during fasting.
- Caffeine in coffee can increase fat breakdown (lipolysis).
- Decaf coffee does not provide the same benefits.
- Adding butter/coconut oil to coffee does not raise blood sugar or insulin but may increase triglycerides.
- Breakfast Considerations:
- Mixed research on the benefits of eating vs. skipping breakfast.
- Adaptation period may be needed to adjust to a new routine.
- Trainability of hunger hormones allows for adaptation over time.
- Seasonal changes may influence breakfast habits.
- Meal Frequency:
- Number of meals within the eating window (2-3 larger meals vs. 4-6 smaller meals) is less important than once believed.
- Personal preference should guide meal frequency.
Quiz Question
Which of the following is recommended when starting with shortened eating windows?
A) Start with a 4-hour eating window and gradually increase it to 12 hours.
B) Fit the eating window within the context of your lifestyle and aim to eat most food when the sun is out.
C) Consume all meals within 2 hours to maximize fasting benefits.
D) Avoid drinking water outside of the eating window.
B) Fit the eating window within the context of your lifestyle and aim to eat most food when the sun is out.