← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 12 - Overlapping Mechanisms
Transcript
It's very likely that there are multiple mechanisms contributing to the beneficial effects of each type of fasting, and that many of these overlap with each other. This table offers a broad overview of the different benefits that may come from each of the different forms of fasting. It's important to note that fasting tends to either have a beneficial or a null effect, and studies that show negative effects of fasting are quite rare. However, such studies do exist. And we should consider them for a minute in order to get as clear of a picture as possible before making a decision on if or how to implement this into our own lives or the lives of people we may work with.
One study used strict alternate day fasting for three weeks, meaning subjects were not getting small 500 calorie meals every other day, but completely fasting for 36 hours at a time. Subjects lost weight, which came from both fat mass and muscle mass, and hunger was increased throughout the trial. Additionally, the improvements in insulin sensitivity were apparent in men but not women. And one other study using one meal per day for two months, which is effectively an extremely shortened eating window, found that blood glucose control was not as good as those who were consuming 3 meals per day.
In this study, the single meal was eaten at dinner time each day. It's worth noting that both of these studies use methods of fasting that are different than what we've generally been looking at. It's likely that occasionally following these specific meal patterns would be fine, but strictly following one meal per day, every day for a long period of time, or alternating 12 hours of eating with 36 hours of fasting for a long period of time would probably not be ideal situations.
In Section 2, we've seen an abundance of research living up to the hype and supporting a number of different forms of fasting, Alternate day fasting, whole day fasting, and short needing windows have all shown improvements in a variety of health markers. In addition to the physiological benefits, it's possible that fasting also improves in individual self-control over hunger and food cravings, which could then translate into better daily food choices or give greater freedom to resist poor food choices when they're the only thing available. At this point, there's not enough information to determine the optimal fasting regimen, meaning the length of the fasting interval, the number of fasting days per week, degree of energy restriction needed on fasting days, as well as recommendations for dietary behavior on non fasting days.
But considering that one of the most important facets of a successful diet is adherence, then figuring out which one, if any, is right for you may be the single most important step. I think a good analogy for fasting could be jazz music. It's the space between the notes that may matter as much or more than the notes themselves.
Outline
Overview of Fasting Benefits and Mechanisms
- Multiple Mechanisms:
- Fasting benefits likely arise from multiple overlapping mechanisms.
- Most studies show beneficial or neutral effects, with few showing negative outcomes.
- Overview of Fasting Benefits:
- General Benefits:
- Weight loss
- Improved insulin sensitivity (not consistently in all populations)
- Enhanced leptin sensitivity
- Reduced inflammation
- Increased autophagy and cellular cleanup
- Improved cognitive function (in some cases)
- Types of Fasting:
- Alternate day fasting
- Whole day fasting
- Shortened eating windows (time-restricted feeding)
Consideration of Negative Effects
- Studies Showing Negative Effects:
- Alternate Day Fasting Study:
- Strict alternate day fasting for three weeks (36-hour fasts) resulted in weight loss from both fat and muscle mass.
- Increased hunger throughout the trial.
- Improvements in insulin sensitivity were observed in men but not women.
- One Meal Per Day Study:
- Subjects eating one meal per day for two months (dinner only) had poorer blood glucose control compared to those consuming three meals per day.
- Insights from Negative Effects:
- Specific Fasting Patterns:
- Strict patterns like one meal per day or prolonged fasting intervals may not be ideal for long-term adherence.
- Occasionally following these specific meal patterns might be acceptable, but strict long-term adherence is not recommended.
Conclusion on Fasting Practices
- Supportive Research:
- Abundant research supports various fasting methods, including alternate day fasting, whole day fasting, and shortened eating windows.
- Potential for fasting to improve self-control over hunger and food cravings, leading to better food choices.
- Unanswered Questions:
- Optimal fasting regimen remains undetermined:
- Length of fasting intervals
- Number of fasting days per week
- Degree of energy restriction on fasting days
- Dietary recommendations on non-fasting days
- Adherence is Key:
- Adherence to a chosen fasting method is crucial for success.
- Fasting can be likened to jazz music—where the space between the notes (fasting periods) matters as much as the notes themselves (eating periods).
Quiz Question
Which of the following is a potential negative effect observed in studies on strict alternate day fasting?
A) Decreased fat mass but increased muscle mass
B) Improved insulin sensitivity in both men and women
C) Increased hunger and weight loss from both fat and muscle mass
D) Enhanced blood glucose control in participants eating one meal per day
C) Increased hunger and weight loss from both fat and muscle mass