← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 04 - Alertness and Task Switching
In this lesson, we'll examine how sleep affects our ability to maintain focus and switch between tasks. We'll also show why even minor sleep loss can significantly impact our cognitive performance.
Transcript
In the last lesson we talked about the two process model for sleep and wake regulation. And we saw that when our wake rhythm get shifted by artificial light at night, then that can cause a gap between process one or sleep pressure and wake drive. And that leads to sleepiness all day long. But it can also lead to disrupted sleep at night. What are some other consequences of poor sleep? Let's take a look. In this first study, we're going to look at decreased vigilant performance.
The way that this is tested is to look at something of the Psycho Motor Vigilance test. So imagine this, you're holding a device in your hands and on that device is 1 screen and one button. And your job is to look at that screen and as soon as you start to see numbers, push that button as fast as you can. It turns out that this is a great way to assess your level of attention. And another thing that's interesting about this test is that you get no better with practice.
So whenever you take this test, it ends up being a very good objective measure of how alert you are in that moment. Now, when you're sleepy, your performance degrades. In this study, they had subjects undergo certain amounts of sleep deprivation from zero hours. So no sleep at all for a few straight days, to only six hours of sleep per night for multiple days to 8 hours of sleep per night as the control. And So what this graph is representing is how poorly you're performing. And it turns out, if you're in the group that's getting no sleep at all over the course of three days, your performance gets worse and worse and worse.
If you're in the group, it's only getting six hours of sleep per night. Your performance also gets worse, but not quite at the same rate. And of course, if you're getting 8 hours of sleep per night, your performance is stable. But notice this If you're only getting six hours of sleep for nine straight days, you're performing as though you've been up for two straight days. And what the authors concluded is that moderate sleep restriction seriously impairs function in healthy young adults, and that these impairments accumulate day after day with inadequate sleep.
But what's also interesting is when we look at subjective sleepiness, or how the subjects report how sleepy they feel now, if they've been up for two straight days, their own report of how sleepy they are almost perfectly matches their objective performance in the previous tests. Look at the shape of this curve. When subjects are only getting six hours of sleep per night, it gets worse for the first few days, but then it levels off. They don't report getting much sleepier.
So you have a situation here where you're not getting feedback to tell you that you're performing worse, and this leads to a state of overestimating your readiness to perform and under estimating your impairment. What about task switching? This is something that we talked about in the first course. Modern work life is filled with task switching as we try to focus on a task and are interrupted with notifications or interruptions in all forms.
After sleep loss, our ability to task switch is seriously impaired. We have impaired accuracy, which means that we have a harder time returning to a point of focus. And knowing where we left off, we have slower speed in our ability to get back to a task and become effective again, and we make more errors switching. And the authors concluded the ability to adjust behavior rapidly and flexibly to changing environmental demands is impacted negatively by sleep loss. Many of us know exactly what this feels like, so one of the impairments with sleep loss is worse task switching.
Outline
- Review of the Two Process Model and Consequences of Misalignment
- Recap of the previous lesson: Impact of artificial light at night on wake rhythm.
- Gap between sleep pressure and wake drive: Leads to daytime sleepiness and disrupted nighttime sleep.
- Introduction to the Consequences of Poor Sleep
- Overview of the effects of insufficient sleep on cognitive performance.
- Study 1: Decreased Vigilant Performance
- Description of the Psycho Motor Vigilance Test (PVT):
- How it measures attention: Participants respond as quickly as possible to visual stimuli.
- Objective measure of alertness: No improvement with practice, making it a reliable assessment.
- Results of the Study:
- Different groups: No sleep, six hours of sleep per night, and eight hours of sleep per night (control).
- Performance degradation with sleep deprivation:
- No sleep: Performance worsens continuously over three days.
- Six hours of sleep per night: Performance degrades but at a slower rate.
- Eight hours of sleep per night: Stable performance.
- Cumulative impact of moderate sleep restriction:
- After nine days of six hours of sleep per night, performance is equivalent to being awake for two straight days.
- Subjective Sleepiness vs. Objective Performance:
- Subjective sleepiness matches objective performance after two days of no sleep.
- Six hours of sleep per night: Subjects do not report feeling much sleepier after the initial days, leading to overestimation of their readiness and underestimation of impairment.
- Task Switching Impairments Due to Sleep Loss
- Modern Work Life and Task Switching:
- Frequent task switching due to notifications and interruptions.
- Impact of Sleep Loss on Task Switching:
- Impaired accuracy: Difficulty returning to the original task and knowing where to resume.
- Slower speed: Delayed ability to refocus and regain effectiveness.
- Increased errors: More mistakes when switching tasks.
- Conclusion: Sleep loss negatively impacts the ability to adjust behavior to changing environmental demands, leading to decreased cognitive flexibility and performance.
Quiz Question
How does moderate sleep restriction (e.g., six hours of sleep per night) over several days affect cognitive performance according to the study on vigilant performance?
- A) It causes only minor impairments with no cumulative effect.
- B) It improves performance due to adaptation over time.
- C) It has no significant effect on cognitive performance.
- D) It results in performance equivalent to being awake for two straight days after nine days.
D) It results in performance equivalent to being awake for two straight days after nine days.