← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 05 - Within Day Activity
Transcript
Think about how many of us perceive exercise in our modern world. We cluster all of our more intense physical activity into a workout. We do these workouts in special locations, like gyms with special clothing, like workout clothes, and we do our very best to squeeze all the workouts we intend to do into our busy week. But is this a natural pattern of movement? If you look at modern day hunter gatherer populations whose lifestyles are likely a good reflection of what our prehistoric ancestors live like, they don't just move in workouts and are then sedentary for most of the rest of the day.
In fact, if you look at their patterns, while they still have a lot of time sitting around and relaxing each day, they also climb and carry and lift and throw and jump. Intermittently across each day. Indeed, muscle activity itself is one of the inputs driving cortical arousal, which is the main reason why muscle relaxants make you drowsy. They relax your muscles, reducing that alerting signal of muscular activation to the brain.
Speaking of reduced muscular activity, in our modern world, even if we're exercising regularly, we do spend an enormous amount of time sitting. Or work oftentimes demands that of us. Is that such a bad thing? Well, we do know that when you fit individuals with headbands that measure blood flow to the brain using ultrasound, you can see that sitting for long periods of time reduces brain blood flow.
Now, earlier in this course we talked about energy capacity systems in response to regular exercise training. Another aspect of energy is blood flow. After all, blood delivers the substrates of energy production. Like blood glucose and fatty acids around the body, but it also delivers oxygen which is also in the energy production process. So blood flow is important for brain energy. And after sitting for a while, taking a walking break restores brain blood flow to normal. And while more walking is better, really good outcomes are achieved with two minutes of walking every half an hour. So I was intrigued when I ran into this quote by Daniel Kahneman. One of the great pleasures is a daily four mile walk on a marked path in the Berkeley hills.
I usually keep track of my time and have learned a fair amount about effort from doing so. I found that at a speed of 17 minutes a mile, I experienced no strain, no conflict, and no need to push myself. I'm also able to think and work while walking at that rate. Indeed, I did some of the best thinking of my life. On leisurely walks with Amos, who he won the Nobel Prize with, accelerating beyond my strolling speed completely changes the experience of walking, because the transition to a faster walk brings about a sharp deterioration in my ability to think coherently. As I speed up, my attention is drawn with increasing frequency to the experience of walking and to the deliberate maintenance of a faster pace.
My ability to bring a train of thought to a conclusion is impaired accordingly. The effects that Kahneman describes here are partly mediated by blood flow. Not that you can't think well when you exert yourself more intensely. It's just that the demands of exercise start to consume more of your focus. Like Kahneman, I have found that long hikes do wonders for solving complex challenges related to work and life. Indeed, there is quite a bit of science to back this up.
Moving helps with thinking. That recognition made me wonder. Can I induce this state more regularly while at work?
Outline
- Modern Perception of Exercise:
- Intense physical activity is often clustered into specific workouts.
- Workouts are performed in designated locations (e.g., gyms) with special clothing.
- We attempt to fit these workouts into our busy schedules.
- Question: Is this pattern of movement natural?
- Natural Movement Patterns:
- Comparison with modern-day hunter-gatherer populations.
- Hunter-gatherers engage in varied movements (e.g., climbing, lifting, throwing) throughout the day.
- Movement is intermittent, not limited to specific workouts.
- Muscle Activity and Cortical Arousal:
- Muscle activity drives cortical arousal (alertness).
- Muscle relaxants reduce this arousal, leading to drowsiness.
- Sedentary Lifestyle in Modern Work:
- Modern work often demands prolonged sitting.
- Prolonged sitting reduces brain blood flow, as measured by headbands with ultrasound.
- Blood Flow and Brain Energy:
- Blood flow delivers energy substrates (glucose, fatty acids) and oxygen to the brain.
- Walking breaks restore brain blood flow to normal levels after sitting.
- Good outcomes are achieved with just two minutes of walking every half hour.
- Daniel Kahneman’s Experience:
- Kahneman’s pleasure in daily walks in the Berkeley Hills.
- He found that walking at a leisurely pace allowed him to think and work effectively.
- Increasing walking speed impaired his ability to think coherently, as more focus was required for the physical activity.
- Kahneman’s insights align with the idea that movement can aid in thinking.
- The Connection Between Movement and Thinking:
- Kahneman’s experience is supported by science: movement enhances cognitive function.
- The challenge: Can this beneficial state be induced more regularly during work?
Quiz Question
What effect does prolonged sitting have on brain blood flow?
- A) It increases brain blood flow, leading to better focus.
- B) It decreases brain blood flow, which can impair cognitive function.
- C) It has no effect on brain blood flow.
- D) It causes an increase in energy production in the brain.
B) It decreases brain blood flow, which can impair cognitive function.