← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 05 - Popular vs Authentic Paleo
Transcript
But curiously, even as the Paleo diet dissipates from mainstream thought, products that are purported to be Paleo have only continued to grow. According to data from market research company IRI Worldwide, the number of paleo themed product launches increased by 35 % in 2016 and US retail sales of products with Paleo in the name have continued to rise as well. I RI Worldwide protected that retail sales of products with the word Paleo in the name could reach as much as four billion dollars by 2020 In fact, you can see this phenomenon for yourself. Go look around specialty food stores or even just your local grocery and you will see plenty of products bearing the Paleo moniker.
Now this kind of sounds like a paradox. Or is it? From the very beginning, Paleo was intended as a departure from the modern pattern of highly processed Neolithic era agricultural foods, and that approach works. A simple diet of lean meats, fish, fruits, and veggies doesn't leave much room on the plate for the worst offenders in the Western diet. But as you probably know, people are all too good at figuring out ways to get around the limitations imposed around any diet, and Paleo is definitely not an exception to this.
If you've ever looked at Paleo recipe blogs, you might have marveled at how perfectly people can replicate our favorite treats. Using ostensibly Paleo ingredients, we can make, quote, unquote, Paleo cookie dough that is pretty much just as hyper palatable as the real stuff, and both of which promote overeating and weight gain. Let's compare a conventional cupcake to a Paleo cupcake. So your standard cupcake would probably be made with all-purpose wheat flour, butter, and granulated white sugar, as well as a few other ingredients. Meanwhile, the Paleo cupcake might be made with almond flour, coconut oil, and probably a blend of coconut sugar and honey.
So sure, the Paleo cupcake is grainfree and dairy free, but is it authentically paleolithic? I think you know the answer. No Paleolithic hunter gatherer would have ever seen any of the ingredients listed on either side of that slide, and the hyperpalatable calorie dense finished product would have been quite foreign to them as well. Junk food with a paleo label would still have many of the problems associated with mainstream junk food, and it is decidedly not Paleolithic. Now this is somewhat speculative, but maybe part of why the Paleo craze has died down is because it has become, at least for some people. All too similar to the unhealthful characteristics of the modern Western diet, then, there is also the ongoing problem of ambiguity to which we alluded earlier.
What is paleo? What is not paleo? This program means to get to the heart of that question, we do have to bear in mind that people approach diets in different ways depending on their own needs, and there's certainly nothing wrong with that. This is particularly true for broad dietary patterns like the Paleolithic diet. With that in mind, we believe that the Paleolithic nutrition pattern can be divided into two poles.
The 1st is authentic Paleo, which is a stricter approach and one that is arguably closer to its true form. It not only includes appropriate food substrates and excludes those that are of Neolithic origin, but also takes into account how they are processed and prepared. For example, the aforementioned Paleo cupcake would certainly not be authentically Paleo because all of the ingredients themselves are Paleolithic. The way that they've been processed and reconstituted certainly is not popular. Paleo, on the other hand, is further in nature from an authentic Paleo diet.
This version maintains the same food substrates and restrictions, but it may also include processed and refined foods that aren't truly a Paleolithic. This would encompass, of course. Said Paleo Cupcake. The idea here is that although we might want to live Paleolithic, we do still live in the Neolithic era and in the modern food environment, making some compromises and processing can help individuals and families stick to their plan, even in situations where it's a bit challenging.
For example, grilled sardines and salad is a perfectly fine choice for a meal, but maybe a bit awkward to serve at a four year old's birthday party. I mean, we wouldn't even know where to insert the candle. Finally, if you are looking for some guidance on how to adopt A Paleolithic diet, regardless of how strict your approach is, we can help. We have a how to guide, which should help you figure out what types of foods to eat or not eat on this dietary pattern, tips on food preparation, and how to personalize the diet to work for you.
And once you've figured that out, we can provide you some more specific ideas of what to eat right now. With our two expertly devised recipe packs, which offer meal ideas that exemplify both popular and authentic Paleo models.
Outline
Introduction: The Paradox of the Modern Paleo Diet
- Continued Growth of Paleo Products
- Market Data: Despite the decline in mainstream popularity, Paleo-themed product launches increased by 35% in 2016.
- Retail Sales: U.S. retail sales of products with "Paleo" in the name have continued to rise, potentially reaching $4 billion by 2020.
- Observation: Paleo-labeled products are prevalent in specialty food stores and local groceries.
The Paradox of Paleo Products
- Original Intent of Paleo
- Dietary Focus: Paleo was intended as a departure from highly processed Neolithic foods, focusing on lean meats, fish, fruits, and vegetables.
- Effectiveness: This approach works by minimizing the intake of unhealthy, processed foods typical of the Western diet.
- Modern Adaptations and Loopholes
- Workarounds: People have found ways to recreate their favorite treats using Paleo ingredients, which can still be hyper-palatable and calorie-dense.
- Example: Comparison of conventional cupcakes made with wheat flour, butter, and sugar to "Paleo" cupcakes made with almond flour, coconut oil, and honey.
- Authenticity Question: Despite being grain-free and dairy-free, such Paleo treats are not authentically Paleolithic, as they are still processed and calorie-dense.
Ambiguity and Decline in Paleo Popularity
- Speculation on Decline
- Similarity to Western Diet: The Paleo diet may have lost some appeal because it has become similar to the unhealthy characteristics of the modern Western diet.
- Ambiguity: Ongoing questions about what is truly Paleo and what is not add to the confusion and decline in popularity.
- Approaches to the Paleo Diet
- Authentic Paleo
- Strict Approach: Focuses on including appropriate food substrates and excludes Neolithic-origin foods while considering processing and preparation methods.
- Example: The Paleo cupcake is not authentically Paleo due to the processed nature of its ingredients.
- Popular Paleo
- More Lenient: Maintains the same food substrates and restrictions but may include processed and refined foods that are not truly Paleolithic.
- Example: Includes foods like the Paleo cupcake that are processed to suit modern tastes and conveniences.
Practical Guidance and Resources
- Personalizing the Paleo Diet
- How-to Guide: Provides information on what types of foods to eat or avoid, tips on food preparation, and how to personalize the diet to suit individual needs.
- Recipe Packs: Offers meal ideas that exemplify both popular and authentic Paleo models.
Quiz Question
Which of the following statements best describes the "Authentic Paleo" approach?
A) It emphasizes foods that are minimally processed and excludes those of Neolithic origin, focusing on preparation methods consistent with Paleolithic practices.
B) It allows for the inclusion of processed and refined foods as long as they are made from Paleo-approved ingredients.
C) It includes any food labeled as "Paleo," regardless of how it is processed or prepared.
D) It allows for the inclusion of grains and dairy as long as they are organic and minimally processed.
A) It emphasizes foods that are minimally processed and excludes those of Neolithic origin, focusing on preparation methods consistent with Paleolithic practices.