← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 02 - Today's Health
Transcript
So what is the underlying appeal of eating like someone from the Paleolithic? Why would people want to, in effect, go backwards in time? In a word, need We have an existing need to improve our health in the modern world. Let's explore this further Before we continue. Please note that in this course we will be looking at research examining modern day hunter gatherer populations. We do this because it is believed that their lifestyles and health outcomes are pretty good reflection of our distant ancestors. At times we will refer to these groups as natural living communities.
Let's talk about life expectancy. Now, the expected lifespan at birth for modern hunter gatherer populations is typically in the thirties and forties. This is due in large part to high infant mortality, but also more deaths across the lifespan. Now, having said that, the modal age of death in traditional populations is 72 years. Not that bad actually. Life expectancy at birth in preindustrial England and Sweden remained very low at 37 to 40 years of age. Now people are living longer than ever. In modern Western nations like the US you can expect to live to or over the age of 80. Here's just one example of the miracle of modern medicine. Infectious disease mortality declined during the first eight decades of the twentieth hundred and ninety seven deaths per one hundred thousand in nineteen hundred all the way down to 36 deaths per 100,000 thousand in 1980 We can attribute this mostly to improved sanitation, as well as the widespread use of antibiotics and vaccines.
This is an awesome triumph of public health, and we shouldn't take it for granted. But despite our great progress, it is not a totally rosy picture. As the Western world gained dominion over the scourge of infectious disease in the twentieth, century chronic diseases, like obesity diabetes, cardiovascular disease and others began to skyrocket in prevalence. In fact, chronic disease is now responsible for about 63 % of deaths worldwide. Why is this? To be fair, it is partially because we are indeed living longer. I mean, we have to die of something, right? If you are lucky enough to elude the infectious diseases that used to claim human lives for most of human history, you are obviously more likely to succumb to something like cancer or cardiovascular disease, for which advanced age is an independent risk factor.
Despite this, it has been reported that while chronic conditions exist in natural living communities. The incidence of such diseases is comparatively low, even in older members of these groups. This is intriguing. So aspects of our modern lifestyle that have changed over the past 10.000 thousand years, or even just the past 50 years, definitely play a role in the modern state of poor health during the lifespan. And one aspect of our lifestyle that has transformed to a massive degree is our diet. We know that diet plays a major role in health. And there's little doubt that the modern Western diet plays a role in chronic disease.
Here is 1 very clear illustration of what I am talking about. So nearly 10 % of Americans currently have type 2 diabetes, and it has been growing in prevalence. Between 1990 and 2010 the number of people living with diabetes tripled and the incidence or number of new cases annually doubled. Now, it is true that people vary in how naturally predisposed they are to developing insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes. However, such a dramatic rise cannot be explained solely by genetics. It is clear that type 2 diabetes is strongly driven by lifestyle factors like diet. Convincing evidence also comes from a number of studies that compare native Japanese to Japanese Americans.
In other words, similar genetics but different environment. And notably different diets, which is confirmed by diet records in these individuals. So this figure shows the relative prevalence of type 2 diabetes in Japanese adults living in Seattle versus Tokyo. As you can see, Japanese Americans live like Americans, eat like Americans, and consequently are sadly much more likely to suffer from type 2 diabetes than counterparts who still live in Japan. When scientists have examined the health markers of modern hunter gatherers, we observe that type 2 diabetes virtually doesn't happen in these people.
Data compiled from 11 populations of natural living communities found on average 1 1 % prevalence of type 2 diabetes. Additionally, the Hadza who live in northern Tanzania, the part of the world where we believe that humans spent most of their evolutionary history as a species. Show very low fasting blood glucose. One study never found a fasting blood sugar reading above 85 milligrams per deciliter, which is pretty low compared to Western averages. Again, people living in industrialized nations show a type 2 diabetes prevalence as high as 10 % and climbing. Please note we are focusing on type 2 diabetes as an illustration of a broader phenomenon. This isn't strictly a diabetes issue. This trend actually appears in a wide array of conditions like hypertension, asthma, osteoarthritis, and even acne or shortsightedness.
These are alarmingly common among people like us, but surprisingly unknown to people who live like our ancient ancestors. Evolutionary biologist Dan Lieberman characterizes all of these conditions as mismatch diseases. He argues that these are examples of our largely Paleolithic bodies being poorly adapted to the conditions of modern living, and diet is obviously a major aspect of this. The food we eat has changed remarkably, but much of our Physiology has not, and we are paying a price for it.
This of course, has given rise to interest in emulating the diet of our ancient ancestors, presumably so that our nutrition is in better alignment with our genome.
Outline
Introduction: The Appeal of the Paleo Diet
- Underlying Appeal
- Reason for Interest: The need to improve modern health outcomes by addressing the mismatch between our biology and modern lifestyle.
- Approach: Studying modern hunter-gatherer populations as a reflection of ancient lifestyles and health outcomes, referred to as "natural living communities."
Life Expectancy and Health in Hunter-Gatherer Populations
- Life Expectancy in Natural Living Communities
- Low Lifespan at Birth: Modern hunter-gatherer populations typically have a life expectancy in the 30s and 40s due to high infant mortality and other lifespan risks.
- Modal Age of Death: Despite low average lifespan, the most common age of death in traditional populations is around 72 years.
- Comparison to Preindustrial and Modern Populations
- Historical Context: Life expectancy at birth in preindustrial England and Sweden was similarly low (37-40 years).
- Modern Improvement: Life expectancy in modern Western nations like the US is over 80 years, largely due to advances in public health and medicine.
- Infectious Disease Decline: Mortality from infectious diseases plummeted in the 20th century due to improved sanitation, antibiotics, and vaccines.
Rise of Chronic Diseases in Modern Societies
- Trade-off of Longevity
- Increased Chronic Disease: As people live longer, chronic diseases like obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease have become more prevalent.
- Chronic Disease Impact: Chronic diseases now account for 63% of deaths worldwide.
- Mismatch Diseases
- Concept: Conditions like type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and others are more common in industrialized societies and rare in natural living communities.
- Dan Lieberman’s Argument: These are "mismatch diseases," resulting from the misalignment between our Paleolithic biology and modern lifestyle.
Diet’s Role in Modern Health Issues
- Modern Western Diet
- Impact on Health: The modern Western diet is a major factor driving the rise in chronic diseases.
- Example: Type 2 Diabetes: Nearly 10% of Americans have type 2 diabetes, a figure that has tripled between 1990 and 2010.
- Comparative Studies
- Japanese vs. Japanese Americans: Similar genetics but different environments and diets show that Japanese Americans have higher rates of type 2 diabetes compared to those living in Japan.
- Hunter-Gatherer Populations: Data shows that type 2 diabetes is virtually nonexistent among these groups, with low fasting blood glucose levels.
- Broader Implications
- Other Conditions: The trend of chronic diseases is seen in various conditions like hypertension, asthma, osteoarthritis, acne, and shortsightedness.
- Interest in the Paleo Diet: The rise in these mismatch diseases has fueled interest in emulating the diet of ancient ancestors to better align nutrition with our genome.
Quiz Question
What term does evolutionary biologist Dan Lieberman use to describe conditions like type 2 diabetes and hypertension, which are common in modern societies but rare in natural living communities?
A) Genetic diseases
B) Evolutionary conditions
C) Mismatch diseases
D) Lifestyle diseases
C) Mismatch diseases