How to Win at Angry Birds
← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 04 - Quadrant Model
Transcript
Earlier I said we would attempt to answer 2 questions. The first was why we failed so spectacularly in finding effective pharmacologic treatments to the health problems of our time, and thus far I've suggested that the answer to that lies in our myopic focus on source code interventions rather than in learning how to play the game. The second question was why we haven't changed our approach in spite of this massive failure. Why we've continued to double down on the Search for Source Code interventions in spite of their disappointing track record, rather than rethinking our underlying strategy. There are likely several reasons why, but one is just because, like the members of Team Source Code, we find reductionism inherently seductive.
Because it's a product of science and reason, and because it's a kind of knowledge that's initially hidden from us, it feels like we've peeled back the curtain to discover something deeper. Something more true and most importantly, more useful. Like Dorothy and her friends, it feels like we've found the man behind the curtain, as I've hopefully illustrated thus far, that couldn't be further from the truth. Yet it's hard to let go of this intuition. It feels like intervening at the source code should be better. Interventions that act this hidden or secret level seem like they should be inherently superior.
This appears to be our natural inclination. Stemming at least in part from a bias towards thinking that this hidden level is more powerful, but also by tapping into our desires to find silver bullets and smoking guns, it's much easier to market and sell silver bullet solutions because they feel easier. It is easier to wrap our minds around problems with a single cause rather than ones that have multiple moving parts that interact in unpredictable ways, but because of these natural biases. And because our incentives often push us further away from the therapeutic solutions we need, I think it's important to create safeguards to formalize the ancestral approach to maintaining health, preventing illness and treating disease.
To create a therapeutic framework that integrates an evolutionary perspective that allows us to be systematic about acquiring and sharing knowledge in this area, to have a common language and a compass for orienting our collective efforts to that end. As a means of formalizing this ancestral health paradigm, and as a means of safeguarding ourselves against the lure of reductionism, I'll now walk through a four quadrant model that categorizes the various kinds of health actions we can take according to our new schema. And that, as you will see, provides a clear guiding framework for prioritizing health decision making. So we can categorize any health action we might take into one of these 4 quadrants.
On the vertical is the level of the intervention, the biological level at which an intervention exerts its effect, the game or the source code. And while these are two ends of a spectrum, most interventions tend to fall primarily into either game or source code level. Remember, game level interventions operate at the level of the evolutionary forces that have shaped our biology. Source code interventions operate at the level of biochemical mechanisms interacting with proteins, receptors, neurotransmitters, and so on.
On the horizontal axis is the goal of the intervention or the health action that we've taken. First, we have actions that are supportive. Supportive interventions are those that activate or amplify the body's ability to achieve health, or in other words, that assist the body in something that it's already trying to do. Interventions of this nature are thus directed towards minimizing or mitigating mismatch by modifying our ordinary daily behaviors to increase the evolutionary concordance in our lives. To make the conditions of our present habitat closer to our natural one, as all of the physiological process which we'd like to optimize have been finally calibrated to that ancestral habitat.
So here we're really using environment to move the balance of normal Physiology in a favorable direction. Disruptive or exploitative interventions are those that are intended to disrupt or exploit the default Physiology in an effort to either enhance biological function or to correct defective functioning. In these cases, we're doing so because we believe that the effects of the disruption are preferred over the default Physiology. Exploitative interventions are similar in that we're taking our understanding of Physiology and exploiting those physiologic mechanisms either to enhance health or function or treat illness, again overriding the physiological status quo.
So in the upper left hand quadrant, which we'll refer to as quadrant one, are interventions or health actions that act at the game level. Or are evolutionarily familiar and that support or assist the body in what it is already trying to do. Examples here would be doing things like eating an ancestral diet that removes evolutionarily novel foods, getting adequate sleep quantity and quality, going outside in the morning or avoiding eating at night to maintain circadian alignment, filtering out blue spectrum light after sunset, and so forth.
These are all the things that we do to bring our present environment more in line with our ancestral 1. Or to reduce environmental mismatch. Our aim is to provide the body with the range of environmental inputs that all of our physiological processes are adapted to, as a means of both optimizing health and preventing the breakdown in Physiology that results from mismatch and is the root driver of chronic diseases. In the upper right quadrant are interventions or actions that are also at the game level, but whose impact is disruptive or exploitative. Here we're making a game level move to alter or manipulate a particular physiological process in order to improve health in some way.
Some examples of actions in this category would be nutritional therapies like the ketogenic diet where we're promoting a particular metabolic state to achieve a specific health outcome. Another might be heat therapy like sauna where we're using a game level exposure like ambient temperature. Not as a means of reducing mismatch, but in order to induce physiological responses that we think are beneficial. Another example here would be mindfulness meditation, to improve the health and function of the brain and body In our lower left quadrant, we have interventions or actions that act at the source code level but are supportive in their impact, An attempt to assist the body in something it's already trying to do.
Once again, these are interventions typically undertaken as a means of reducing mismatch. In this category, we'd have things like specific vitamins and minerals that we would have obtained in adequate amounts in our ancestral habitat, but that are commonly insufficient in our present one. For example, we tend to spend significantly less time outdoors in direct sunlight in our modern environment, which is why vitamin D deficiency is so widespread. One way to reduce that mismatch would be to take a vitamin D supplement, the dissociation of our daily rhythms from the rise and fall of the sun.
Can result in degradation of our sleep wake cycle, and one potential way to mitigate the impact of that mismatch would be to take supplemental melatonin. The typical Western diet is deficient in several essential vitamins and minerals, and taking those in purified form would be a means of reducing that particular mismatch. Again, these are examples of mismatches that result in the body not having sufficient amounts of the raw materials it needs to carry out normal physiological processes.
Our last quadrant in the lower right corner contains source code interventions that are disruptive, where again, we're attempting to override a physiological process to promote better health. That may seem like a bold and risky thing to do, so where might it make sense to do so? The primary scenario where we might want to do such a thing is when one of the body's regulatory systems has broken past the point of no return. Injecting insulin for diabetes would be one example. In this case, the system for regulating blood glucose is broken, as the body has lost its primary means of doing so because of disease.
Now the physiological status quo can result in dangerously high blood glucose levels, so it can make sense to alter that with a source code intervention. Another example would be hyper supplementation, meaning taking a particular supplement like a vitamin past the point that's needed to support baseline physiological functions. In order to achieve some kind of medicinal effect, a large dose of magnesium, for example, to relieve Constipation, or large quantities of vitamin C to shorten the duration of an upper respiratory infection.
In these instances, we're using our understanding of biology at the source code level to manipulate a certain part of it to either enhance function health or to treat illness, and so the prioritization schema according to the argument I've just outlined. Would be that interventions in quadrant one would be favored over those in quadrant 2, which are favored over those in quadrant 3, which are favored over those in quadrant 4. Our primary interventions we utilize to promote health and treat illness should be game level and supportive, and our last resorts should be those that are source code level and disruptive.
The only instance where we would deviate from this rule. Would be if we had clear head to head evidence indicating that an intervention in a higher quadrant was superior than an intervention in a lower quadrant.
Outline
Failure in Pharmacologic Treatments
- Two Key Questions:
- Why lack of effective treatments?
- Why no change in approach despite failures?
- Source Code Focus: Myopic focus on source code interventions cited as primary reason for failure.
- Attraction to Reductionism: Seductive nature of uncovering hidden knowledge.
Ancestral Health Approach
- Creation of Safeguards: Formalizing ancestral health to prevent illness and promote health.
- Integrating Evolutionary Perspective: Systematic knowledge sharing and common language for health actions.
Four Quadrant Model
- Framework: Categorizes health actions into four quadrants based on intervention level and goal.
- Vertical Axis: Game level (evolutionary forces) vs. Source code level (biochemical mechanisms).
- Horizontal Axis: Supportive (activating body’s health mechanisms) vs. Disruptive/Exploitative (altering default physiology).
Quadrant Descriptions
- Upper Left (Quadrant 1): Game level and supportive.
- Examples: Ancestral diet, adequate sleep, circadian alignment, reducing environmental mismatch.
- Upper Right (Quadrant 2): Game level, disruptive/exploitative.
- Examples: Ketogenic diet, heat therapy, mindfulness meditation.
- Lower Left (Quadrant 3): Source code level, supportive.
- Examples: Vitamin D supplementation, melatonin for sleep, nutrient supplementation.
- Lower Right (Quadrant 4): Source code level, disruptive.
- Examples: Insulin for diabetes, high-dose vitamin C for infections.
Prioritization Schema
- Preference Order: Quadrant 1 > Quadrant 2 > Quadrant 3 > Quadrant 4.
- Primary Interventions: Focus on game level and supportive actions.
- Exception: Clear evidence favoring higher quadrant intervention over lower.
Quiz Yourself
- What is the primary reason for the continued focus on source code interventions despite their limited success in addressing health problems?
- Lack of understanding about game-level interventions.
- Reductionism is inherently seductive and feels like it reveals deeper, more useful truths.
- Source code interventions are cheaper and easier to implement.
- There is a legal requirement to prioritize source code interventions.
- According to the four-quadrant model, what characterizes interventions in the upper left quadrant (Quadrant 1)?
- They are source code level and disruptive.
- They act at the game level and are supportive, assisting the body in what it's already trying to do.
- They are source code level and supportive.
- They are game level but intended to disrupt or exploit default physiology.
- B
- Why are interventions that are source code level and disruptive considered as the last resort in the prioritization schema?
- A. Because they are the most expensive and difficult to administer.
- B. They are favored only if clear evidence shows superiority over lower quadrant interventions.
- They are less effective than game-level interventions in all cases.
- There is no scientific basis for their effectiveness.
- B
B