How Much Physical Activity Do We Need?
← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 07 - Physical Activity and Mortality
Transcript
So we have established why, on a fundamental level, getting the right dose of physical activity is health promoting not too little but also not too much. Now let's talk about how getting appropriate levels of movement affects your lifespan. So according to the 2018 US Physical Activity Guidelines Advisory Committee, we should aim for either a hundred fifty to three hundred minutes per week of moderate activity or 75 to one hundred fifty minutes of vigorous activity per week for substantial health benefits.
How many people do you think actually meet those recommendations? You might not be surprised to hear that it's. Well, it's not that many yeah currently, on average, only about 23 % of American adults meet the guidelines. Even children, who we tend to think of as having boundless energy, are falling short. Just 35 % of girls and 49 % of boys between the ages of 6 to 11 are performing sufficient physical activity. Let's look at the consequences of this lack of activity and see how much you might benefit from meeting or even exceeding the activity guidelines.
A team of scientists compiled results from six different studies examining 660,000 thousand adults to determine how different levels of physical activity are related to risk of dying in subsequent years. They collected information about their leisure time physical activity at baseline, then track the health of the participants for an average of 14 years. These adults were then split into groups based on their activity levels. So on the Y axis, we're looking at risk of death in the period of time analyzed in the study. Higher up on the Y axis means higher risk of death, and as you go lower on the axis, the risk for death decreases.
So lower is better. On this graph and on the X axis we are looking at 7 different groupings of people. These different groups represent different average amounts of physical activity. A key point of reference is group number three. This group is doing the exact amount of physical activity recommended in the guidelines. Remember how the guidelines advise one hundred fifty to three hundred minutes of moderate intensity physical activity per week? Well, 100 % - one hundred fifty minutes of moderate activity and 200 % - 300 minutes of moderate activity per week.
Now if you were in groups four to seven, you would have gotten more than the guidelines. And if you were in groups one or two, you would have been getting less activity than the guidelines recommend. So let's look at how likely these people were to die from any cause in the ensuing years. By the way, you might note that the shape of this graph is quite similar to that stress response curve or Hormesis dose response curve that I showed you earlier.
Compared to people reporting no activity in Group one, those in Group 2 reporting some activity but less than the guidelines were 20 % less likely to die. Meanwhile, those doing the recommended volume of physical activity were 31 % less likely to die. People doing three to five times the recommended minimum amount of activity were 39 % less likely to die. And those who did the most activity had a 31 % reduced risk of dying compared to the most sedentary group One.
And by the way, those doing the most physical activity had the same relative risk of death as those meeting the guideline recommendations. Incidentally, we don't know for sure if this means that a very high amount of activity really starts to become increasingly less healthy. This data is correlational, and I can imagine a lot of different factors that might contribute to this finding, but it certainly looks that way. Now, Three things about these findings are especially noteworthy. First of all, the steepest part of the orange line is from no activity at all to some activity.
This suggests that going from no leisure time physical activity to even just a little may dramatically reduce risk of dying from any cause. So if you're currently sedentary, realize that just sitting a little less and moving a little more may produce huge health benefits for you. Secondly, the results imply that doing the recommended amount of physical activity is indeed associated with the majority of the benefits. Third, high and even very high levels of physical activity don't appear to be harmful.
Like all studies, this work does have some limitations, but it certainly provides compelling evidence that the current physical activity guidelines are reasonable targets for most of us to shoot for. And if you feel the urge to do more, that's probably just fine as well.
Outline
Introduction: Appropriate Levels of Physical Activity and Lifespan
- Physical Activity Guidelines
- The 2018 US Physical Activity Guidelines recommend:
- 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity per week, or
- 75 to 150 minutes of vigorous activity per week for substantial health benefits.
Current Activity Levels in the Population
- Low Compliance Rates
- Only 23% of American adults meet these physical activity guidelines.
- Even among children, activity levels are low, with only 35% of girls and 49% of boys ages 6 to 11 meeting recommended levels.
Study on Physical Activity and Mortality Risk
- Study Overview
- Data from six studies involving 660,000 adults were analyzed to determine how physical activity levels relate to mortality risk.
- Participants' physical activity was tracked over an average of 14 years, and they were grouped based on activity levels.
- Graph Interpretation
- Y-Axis: Risk of death during the study period (lower is better).
- X-Axis: Seven groups based on average physical activity levels.
- Group 3: Meets the guidelines (150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity per week).
- Groups 4-7: Exceed the guidelines.
- Groups 1-2: Fall short of the guidelines.
Key Findings on Activity Levels and Mortality Risk
- Comparing Groups
- Group 2 (some activity but less than the guidelines): 20% lower risk of death compared to Group 1 (no activity).
- Group 3 (meets the guidelines): 31% lower risk of death compared to Group 1.
- Groups 4-5 (3 to 5 times the recommended activity): 39% lower risk of death.
- Group 7 (most activity): 31% lower risk of death, same as Group 3.
Implications of the Findings
- Significance of Small Increases in Activity
- The steepest drop in mortality risk occurs from no activity to some activity.
- Even small increases in physical activity can significantly reduce mortality risk.
- Benefits of Meeting the Guidelines
- The majority of the health benefits are associated with meeting the recommended activity levels.
- High Levels of Activity
- High and very high levels of physical activity are not associated with increased harm.
- However, the benefits plateau at higher levels of activity, suggesting diminishing returns.
Conclusion
- Takeaway
- The current physical activity guidelines are reasonable targets for most people.
- Exceeding the guidelines is likely beneficial, but even small increases in activity can lead to significant health improvements.
Quiz Question
Which of the following best describes the relationship between physical activity levels and mortality risk according to the study?
A) Meeting the recommended physical activity levels is associated with a significant reduction in mortality risk, and even small increases in activity provide substantial benefits.
B) Only very high levels of physical activity reduce the risk of death; lower levels have no effect.
C) There is no difference in mortality risk between those who are active and those who are sedentary.
D) Exceeding the recommended levels of physical activity significantly increases the risk of death.
A) Meeting the recommended physical activity levels is associated with a significant reduction in mortality risk, and even small increases in activity provide substantial benefits.