← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 06 - Polarized Training
Transcript
The next area we'll focus on something called polarized training. First, let's revisit that simplified training intensity zone scheme that we introduced earlier in this course. The green parts represent a relatively easy low intensity activity. Then you cross the lactate threshold into the yellow section, where lactate begins to accumulate in the blood. But your oxygen consumption, heart rate, and lactate levels will all reach a stable level. You're breathing harder, and it becomes a bit tougher to string words together. This yellow zone is actually where a lot of people wind up spending much of their training time. What do a lot of folks do when they decide to train for a race? If you think about it, they'll often go out and justice jog at this medium pace, roughly the highest pace that they're able to sustain for 30 minutes or an hour. So they're running at an intensity that lies between these two thresholds, and we call this a lactate threshold training model. Another approach is to spend most of your training time below marathon pace or equivalent. If you're cycling, then spend some time at a higher intensity zone 3. This is referred to as a polarized training model because it polarizes most of your training away from the middle and off to two sides, as illustrated by the J curve in the graph on the left. So which approach is better? Let's take a look at a study that compares these two models of training. So one thing you have to note here is that the group using the threshold training approach had significantly more training time, almost an hour or more per week. They sent 57% of their time in zone one, easy training 43 % of their time in Zone 2, and no time and Zone 3. The individuals in the polarized training group spent 80% of their time in zone one, no time in Zone 2, and 20 % of their time in Zone 3. So what happened? After six weeks of training, both groups improved. So one takeaway here is that pretty much any endurance training you perform is at to be beneficial. But if we zoom in closer, we'll see far greater improvements in the polarized training group than in the threshold training group. And bear in mind the polarized group was training an hour less per week. At the top we see peak power output, which refers to the highest power output achieved during a graded exercise test, meaning a test that starts easy and gets harder every minute. As we can see, the polarized group enjoyed a much greater improvement in their highest attainable power output. Next is lactate threshold, which is the maximal effort or intensity that one can maintain for an extended period of time with minimal increase in lactate levels. You would probably think that the best way to improve your lactate threshold is to train at the lactate threshold or Zone 2, right? But perhaps counterintuitively, avoiding the lactate threshold entirely by performing polarized training resulted in greater improvement in the lactate threshold itself. This is a very interesting and important observation, and suggests that many people are not getting the most out of their training. Finally, we see that these boosts in peak power output and lactate threshold translated to greater performance in a 40 kilometer cycling time trial for the third time. Here, polarized training is the clear winner. Here's another study comparing the impact of training intensity distribution this time and endurance runners. These distributions of intensity are a little different than previously described. One is 80 % in zone one ten percent % two and 10 % in Zone 3 and this is represented as eighty ten and the other is sixty five twenty five ten. On the vertical axis you see race time and seconds and on the horizontal axis you see the race performance of the two groups before and after training. And as you can see, the 8010 ten group, the more polarized group spending most of their time in Zone 1 improves more than the group spending more time in Zone 2. I think this is a useful way to view training intensity in light of what we've discussed here regarding polarized training. Most people, when they get into aerobic training, get pulled into that black hole in the center representing the lactate threshold or zone 2. But evidence suggests that it may actually be advantageous to instead gravitate towards the extremes, meaning 65 % and 90 % intensity training zones, and avoid falling into the middle.
Outline
Introduction to Polarized Training
- Revisiting Training Intensity Zones:
- Green Zone: Low-intensity, easy activity.
- Yellow Zone: Medium intensity, lactate accumulation begins, but levels stabilize.
- Common Practice: Many people spend a lot of training time in the yellow zone, known as lactate threshold training.
Lactate Threshold vs. Polarized Training
- Lactate Threshold Training:
- Typical Approach: Training at the highest pace sustainable for 30-60 minutes, primarily in the yellow zone.
- Polarized Training:
- Training Distribution: Most time is spent in the green zone (low intensity) and some in the red zone (high intensity).
- J-Curve Distribution: Training is polarized away from the middle intensity (yellow zone).
Study Comparison: Lactate Threshold vs. Polarized Training
- Study Overview:
- Threshold Training Group: 57% in Zone 1, 43% in Zone 2, no time in Zone 3.
- Polarized Training Group: 80% in Zone 1, 20% in Zone 3, no time in Zone 2.
- Training Time: Polarized group trained an hour less per week.
- Results:
- Peak Power Output: Greater improvement in the polarized group.
- Lactate Threshold: Surprisingly, the polarized group saw greater improvement, despite not training in the lactate threshold zone.
- 40km Cycling Time Trial Performance: Polarized training resulted in better performance.
Study on Endurance Runners
- Intensity Distributions:
- 80/10/10 Group: 80% in Zone 1, 10% in Zone 2, 10% in Zone 3.
- 65/25/10 Group: 65% in Zone 1, 25% in Zone 2, 10% in Zone 3.
- Race Performance:
- The more polarized 80/10/10 group improved more than the 65/25/10 group.
Key Takeaways
- Avoiding the "Black Hole": Many athletes get stuck in the lactate threshold zone, which may not be the most effective training strategy.
- Advantage of Extremes: Polarized training, focusing on low and high intensities while minimizing time in the middle, seems to be more effective for endurance improvements.
Quiz Question
Which training approach has been shown to result in greater improvements in peak power output and lactate threshold in endurance athletes?
A) Lactate Threshold Training
B) Polarized Training
C) High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT)
D) Steady-State Training
B) Polarized Training