← Last Lesson | Next Lesson →
Lesson 05 - The Problem With Food Reward
Transcript
Now let's see how this might play out in the life of a hypothetical person named laura is a person who is overweight and cares about her weight and health and tries to eat healthy. Sometimes she succeeds, but temptation frequently undermines her best intentions. At home, Laura usually cooks meals for herself, but she often has corn chips on the counter and salsa in the fridge. She tells herself it's OK as long as she only eats a small quantity of them, which would be true except for the fact that she usually eats more than she intends to.
Laura eats most of her meals at home and cooks healthy vegetable and meat dishes, but calorie dense, prepared foods like crackers, cheese, and white bread often make up a large part of her meals. She has a reputation as a good cook. And part of the reason is that she doesn't hold back on the added fats when she makes a dish. She adds a lot of fat and salt because she likes the taste, and she also adds a lot of cream and sugar to her tea in the morning for the same reason. She also enjoys baking and uses it as a way to experience pleasure and express her affection for others. In many ways, she likes how she eats.
But it drives her to consume hundreds of extra calories per day, in part because of the very high reward value of her food. She eats more than she needs to feel full at a meal, and food reward cues in her environment drive her to eat between meals as well. She often gets cravings when she sees food ads on TV She knows she eats too much sometimes, but her cravings are so strong she feels powerless to resist them. At work, Laura is surrounded by temptation between her own baked goods and those of her coworkers.
There are often cookies or brownies around. Usually these are related to special occasions like birthdays, promotions and holidays, sometimes also staff meetings. All told, there are tempting baked goods in the office about three times a week. When these foods are around, their appearance and smell are overwhelming to Laura, and she usually eats them despite the fact that she isn't particularly hungry. This might seem like a dire situation, but food reward has a flip side that Laura can exploit to help control her weight. While excessive food reward can drive us to overeat, reducing food reward can help us eat less and lose weight more sustainably. Let's take a look at some of the evidence.
In 1989 researchers published a study that clearly illustrated the power of reducing food reward to control hunger and calorie intake. To reduce food reward to the bare minimum, researchers restricted 4 volunteers to a bland liquid diet with no other food. It wasn't a weight loss study, and they were allowed to drink as much of the liquid as they wanted. Yet over three weeks, their calorie intake spontaneously declined and they lost seven pounds of body weight. Remarkably, they reported that they were eating to fullness and didn't feel hungry. To see how this response compares to what happens with regular portion control, the same researchers had a second group of volunteers lose the same amount of weight over the same period of time, seven pounds over three weeks.
Yet this time they did it by simply eating less of their typical diet. The effect on the volunteers was totally different, even though they lost the same amount of weight over the same period of time, To quote the researchers, they, quote had to continually fight off their hunger and would spend the night dreaming of food. End Quote. The researchers concluded that food reward has a powerful effect on how the brain regulates appetite. Other studies have reported similar findings that drastically reducing food reward has a remarkable ability to restrain appetite and promote weight loss without hunger. Unfortunately, as you may have surmised already, there is a drawback here.
Most people are simply unwilling to give up the pleasures of the palate. And even among those who are willing to give it up, it's unlikely to be sustainable. So rather than being Spartan, we're going to try to strike a wise balance between effectiveness and comfort. What can we do to control food reward in the most painless and sustainable way possible? Let's see how we can use these principles we've covered to support weight management.
Outline
Laura's Situation
- Current Eating Habits:
- Laura cooks most of her meals at home, focusing on healthy vegetable and meat dishes.
- Frequently tempted by calorie-dense, prepared foods like crackers, cheese, and white bread.
- Adds significant amounts of fat, salt, cream, and sugar to her dishes and beverages.
- Uses baking as a way to experience pleasure and express affection.
- Impact of Food Reward:
- High reward value of her food leads to overeating during meals and snacking between meals.
- Experiences strong cravings, especially when exposed to food cues like ads on TV.
- At work, surrounded by tempting baked goods, leading to frequent indulgence despite not being hungry.
Reducing Food Reward
- Research Evidence:
- 1989 study showed that reducing food reward can lead to spontaneous calorie reduction and weight loss.
- Volunteers on a bland liquid diet ate to fullness and lost weight without feeling hungry.
- In contrast, those who lost weight through portion control experienced constant hunger and food cravings.
- Challenges:
- Drastically reducing food reward is effective but unsustainable for most people.
- Complete removal of food pleasure is not a viable long-term solution for many.
Balanced Approach
- Goal:
- Strike a balance between reducing food reward to support weight management while maintaining comfort and enjoyment in eating.
- Focus on sustainable methods to control food reward without giving up all pleasures of eating.
Quiz Question
Which of the following describes the impact of reducing food reward based on research findings?
A) It leads to increased hunger and cravings.
B) It results in spontaneous calorie reduction and weight loss without hunger.
C) It has no effect on calorie intake or weight loss.
D) It only works if combined with portion control.
B) It results in spontaneous calorie reduction and weight loss without hunger.